Admission From Smart Parking – Goose Green Car Park Altrincham

Smart Parking Altrincham

As you know we ran a story about Smart Parking sending out multiple invoices (They call them PCNs) to visitors to Goose Green car park in Altrincham. The invoices were sent regardless of whether the users had purchased a ticket from one of the unfathomable machines or not.

We have now received this response from their communications company Mediazoo (who claimed they didn’t receive our email asking them for an explanation!). You’ll note they don’t provide any apology for this mishap!

The statement comes from a Smart Parking spokesperson;

“Smart Parking are one of the UK’s largest parking operators and we manage the Altrincham Car Park.

At the car park we use a state of the art ANPR system to ensure motorists can always find places to park and that everyone is treated fairly and equally. 

In order to improve the customer journey, in early December we added an extra registration machine to the site at Total Fitness.  However, we subsequently found out that this particular machine wasn’t registered correctly and erroneously issued a number of parking charges.   On discovering the issue, we addressed immediately and the machine is now operating correctly.  In addition, we also identified all motorists incorrectly issued with notices, cancelled them and despatched letter confirming the same.  Further, we will also be issuing reimbursements to relevant motorists.

As proud members of the British Parking Association, Smart Parking strictly follow its guidelines.  As such, we operate a BPA audited appeals process and would encourage anyone to contact us if they feel they have been charged incorrectly.”

We would love to know if any of our readers have received letters and refunds from Smart. Also whether you have received any apology or indeed compensation for the stress and anguish involved, which we feel would be perfectly acceptable to pursue given the circumstances.

Please let us know in the comments below or on our Facebook page.

Lenny Brick


See original story here:


  1. Hi

    I received a letter from Smart Parking the same week as the story was issued. I appealed and today received a letter to say that they have decided to uphold the PCN despite me sending them communication confirming that I took my 2 young children swimming and receive free parking for 2 hours. I put my registration number in the machine (as I always do) and despite them admitting there has been an issue with a parking machine they still say that they cannot find my registration number. This has caused me a lot of stress and upset. I am now thinking of stopping swimming lessons for my 2 young boys (which is a life skill) because of receiving this parking notice. I am writing to them to submit a formal complaint but don’t think I have been fairly treated at all.

  2. Hi,

    I have been served 13 parking charge notices dated between 6 June 2019 and 8 July 2019 to which Smart Parking are invoicing me between £60-£100 per ticket

    As you my be aware, the Goose Green Multi-Storey Car Park in Altrincham, has been under heavy construction for several months which has caused the ticket machines in the Car Park to stop working.

    The Car Park is utilised by Total Fitness members, myself included. Total Fitness members have access to two (2) hours free parking whilst at the gym. The issue with the ticket machines was relayed to the staff at Total Fitness who confirmed to me (and other gym goers), that the ticket machines had been consistently broken since the construction began and therefore, gym users could not pay for parking tickets. Upon entry and exit to the gym, the Total Fitness computer system logs a user’s entry and exit to the gym.

    As far as I understand it, a Parking Charge Notice, such as the 13 I have been issued with are an invoice alleging a breach of contract for using goods or services without a valid ticket. The basic principles of entering into a contract are 1) offer, 2) acceptance 3) consideration and 4) intention. I suggest that a legally binding contract has not been entered into and therefore, no such enforcement action for a breach can be taken. I was unable to fulfil the consideration requirement as the ticket machines were broken therefore, meaning I could not pay (provide the requisite consideration) for a ticket.

    This is not a case where the machine was working and I simply did not purchase a ticket, Smart Parking machines were not working and therefore, no such tickets could be purchased. Under these circumstances, I have request Smart Parking withdraw the 13 parking charge notices referred to in the email.

    I have appealed with this note along with evidence of print screens of my gym access across June/July which has been provided by Total Fitness. They have also since replied upholding their charges with no justification as to why and no specific comments made to my appeal

    I too wish to claim compensation for stress and anxiety suffered from this on-going unfair process.

  3. Does anyone know if disabled parking is free in goose green multi storey carpark cause I took my 82 year old mother for a hearing test and she has a blue badge and we were fined £100 for not paying. We assumed it was free.
    I’ve made an appeal but proof of blue badge and hearing test appointment wont upload.
    Has anyone been granted an appeal yet?


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.